Best Paper Award
| Emmanuel Destenay | |
|---|---|
| Affiliation | Sorbonne University |
| Country | France |
| Article Title | Silencing Dissent and Eradicating Disloyalty in the Classroom: Identity, Patriotism, and Moral Restraint in Wartime America, 1917–1918 |
| Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
| Publication Year | 2026 |
| DOI | 10.1017/S1537781426101686 |
| Scopus | 57189625111 |
| ORCID | 0000-0002-4760-1992 |
| Documents | 17 |
| Citations | 10 |
| h-index | 2 |
| Award Category | Best Paper Award |
| Event | International Research Awards |
The Best Paper Award recognizes scholarly publications that demonstrate academic quality, originality, methodological strength, and meaningful contributions to their respective research disciplines. Emmanuel Destenay’s article, Silencing Dissent and Eradicating Disloyalty in the Classroom: Identity, Patriotism, and Moral Restraint in Wartime America, 1917–1918, examines the relationship between educational institutions, political dissent, national identity, and patriotism during the First World War. [1]
Abstract
This article examines the suppression of political dissent anthe enforcement of loyalty within American educational institutions during the First World War, particularly between 1917 and 1918. It explores how teachers, academic organizations, and educational authorities responded to wartime expectations concerning patriotism, national identity, and professional responsibility. [1]
Keywords
American History, World War I, Educational History, Academic Freedom, Political Dissent, Patriotism, National Identity, Wartime Education, Teachers, Professional Responsibility, Democratic Education, Freedom of Expression, Progressive Era, Intellectual Freedom, Political Loyalty. [1]
Introduction
The United States’ participation in the First World War created significant changes in political culture, public institutions, and educational practices. Teachers and university academics faced increasing expectations to demonstrate loyalty to national objectives, while expressions of political disagreement could attract institutional scrutiny.[1]
Scientific Background
The historical background of the study concerns the relationship between national security, public education, and freedom of expression during wartime America. Following the country’s entry into World War I, government policies and public expectations placed increased emphasis on national unity and patriotic conduct. Educational institutions became important settings in which questions of loyalty, citizenship, and political disagreement were addressed.[1]
Research Methodology
The article employs a historical research approach to examine educational and institutional responses to dissent during 1917–1918. Its analysis considers historical developments, institutional debates, professional organizations, and contemporary expectations concerning patriotic conduct. The study investigates how teachers, educational administrators, and academic associations interpreted professional responsibility during wartime. [1]
Key Findings
The research highlights how wartime expectations of loyalty influenced teachers and academic institutions in the United States. It examines the ways political dissent could be interpreted as disloyalty and how educational organizations responded to pressures for patriotic conformity [1]
Research Contributions
The article contributes to the study of American educational history by examining how wartime political conditions influenced professional expectations and institutional practices. Its discussion connects classroom experiences with broader academic debates about patriotism, political loyalty, and freedom of expression. [1]
Scientific Impact
The article has relevance to historical scholarship concerning education, political culture, and democratic freedoms. Its examination of wartime educational institutions provides context for understanding how political emergencies can influence professional independence and public expressions of disagreement. The supplied Scopus profile records 17 documents, 10 citations, and an h-index of 2. [2]
Award Suitability
The featured publication demonstrates characteristics relevant to consideration under the Best Paper Award category of the International Research Awards. These include its focused historical investigation, engagement with educational and institutional questions, scholarly discussion of wartime political culture, and contribution to research on academic freedom.[3]
Conclusion
Emmanuel Destenay’s article provides a historical examination of the relationship between political dissent, patriotism, educational institutions, and professional responsibility during the First World War. By focusing on wartime America between 1917 and 1918, the study explores how national expectations influenced teachers and academic organizations. [1]
External Links
References
- Destenay, E. (2026). Silencing Dissent and Eradicating Disloyalty in the Classroom: Identity, Patriotism, and Moral Restraint in Wartime America, 1917–1918. The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Cambridge University Press.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S1537781426101686 - Scopus. (n.d.). Emmanuel Destenay: Author Profile, Author ID 57189625111. Elsevier Scopus.
https://www.scopus.com/authid/detail.uri?authorId=57189625111 - Cambridge University Press. (2026). The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Cambridge Core.
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-gilded-age-and-progressive-era